Discover the Creamiest Scoops: Unveiling Cincinnati's Top 10 Best Ice Cream Shops!

Indulge in the creamy goodness of Cincinnati's best ice cream. From classic flavors to unique creations, satisfy your sweet tooth today.

Cincinnati is known for its delicious food, and ice cream is no exception. With so many options to choose from, it can be hard to decide where to go for the best ice cream in town. But fear not, we’ve done the research and found the top spots for you to satisfy your sweet tooth.

If you’re a lover of classic flavors, look no further than Graeter’s. This Cincinnati staple has been around since 1870 and is famous for their French Pot ice cream, which is made in small batches and churned by hand. Their Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip flavor is a must-try and has been voted the best ice cream in America by the Huffington Post.

For those who prefer a more unique taste, head over to Aglamesis Brothers. This family-owned and operated ice cream shop has been serving up hand-crafted treats since 1908. Their flavors range from traditional, like vanilla bean, to adventurous, like lavender honey or banana walnut fudge.

If you’re looking for a place to cool off on a hot summer day, head to the charming neighborhood of Oakley and stop by the cheerful storefront of Buzzed Bull Creamery. This spot offers alcoholic ice cream treats like spiked milkshakes and boozy sorbets. And for those who don’t drink alcohol, they also have plenty of non-alcoholic options for you to enjoy.

Another great option is Dojo Gelato, which offers a rotating selection of flavors made with locally sourced ingredients. Their seasonal flavors are always worth trying, whether it’s the refreshing lemon basil in the summer or the comforting cinnamon in the fall.

If you’re in the mood for some nostalgia, check out Zip Dip. This classic drive-up ice cream stand has been serving up soft serve cones and milkshakes since 1950. Their signature flavor is the Black Raspberry Chip, but they also have plenty of other options to choose from.

For a more upscale ice cream experience, head to the artisanal ice cream shop, The Bonbonerie. Their flavors are inspired by European desserts and their ice cream is made in small batches with fresh ingredients. Their salted caramel flavor is a fan favorite and it’s easy to see why.

One of the newest additions to the Cincinnati ice cream scene is Cream + Sugar. This trendy spot offers unique flavors like lavender honey and matcha green tea, as well as classic flavors like chocolate and vanilla. And if you’re feeling extra indulgent, try one of their ice cream sandwiches made with homemade cookies.

If you’re vegan or lactose intolerant, don’t worry, there’s still a spot for you to enjoy delicious ice cream in Cincinnati. The Loving Hut offers a variety of vegan ice cream flavors made with coconut milk and soy milk. Their peanut butter cup flavor is a must-try for any peanut butter lover.

Lastly, if you’re looking for a fun date night spot, check out The Cone. This ice cream stand is located inside a vintage gas station and offers a romantic atmosphere with outdoor seating and string lights. Their flavors range from classic to creative, and they even offer a “flight” option for those who can’t decide on just one flavor.

No matter what your ice cream preferences are, Cincinnati has something for everyone. These top spots are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth and leave you wanting more.

Introduction

If you're looking for a cold, sweet treat to cool you down on a hot summer day in Cincinnati, there's no better option than ice cream. With so many fantastic options in the city, it can be tough to choose where to go. To help you out, we've put together a list of the best ice cream spots in Cincinnati.

Graeter's Ice Cream

No discussion of Cincinnati ice cream would be complete without mentioning Graeter's. This iconic local chain has been serving up delicious ice cream since 1870, and it's still going strong. Their handcrafted French pot ice cream is made in small batches, giving it a creamy, rich texture that sets it apart from other brands. Their signature flavor, Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, is a must-try.

Dojo Gelato

If you're looking for something a little different than traditional ice cream, head to Dojo Gelato. This artisanal gelato shop serves up unique flavors like Thai Basil, Honey Lavender, and Bourbon Pecan. All of their gelato is made in-house using fresh, local ingredients, so you can feel good about your indulgence.

Aglamesis Brothers

Aglamesis Brothers is another Cincinnati institution with a long history of serving up delicious ice cream. This family-owned and operated business has been around since 1908, and they're still making their ice cream the same way they did back then. Their classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry are always popular, but don't miss out on their seasonal flavors like pumpkin and eggnog.

Zip Dip

If you're looking for a classic ice cream stand experience, head to Zip Dip. This family-owned business has been serving up soft serve ice cream since 1950, and it's still a local favorite. Their signature Zip Dip swirl is a delicious combination of vanilla and chocolate, and they also offer a variety of other flavors and toppings.

Madisono's Gelato

Madisono's is another local gelato shop that's worth checking out. Their gelato is made using traditional Italian methods, and they offer a wide variety of flavors, from classic options like chocolate and pistachio to more unique options like fig and goat cheese or lavender honey. They also offer sorbetto for those who are dairy-free.

The Dairy Bar

The Dairy Bar is a classic ice cream stand that's been serving up sweet treats since 1950. They offer a variety of soft serve flavors, as well as hand-dipped options, sundaes, and shakes. Their hot fudge sundae is a classic choice, but don't miss out on their seasonal flavors like pumpkin and peppermint stick.

Bonomini Bakery

Bonomini Bakery is best known for their delicious baked goods, but they also offer homemade ice cream that's worth trying. Their ice cream is made in-house using fresh, local ingredients, and they offer a variety of classic flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry, as well as more unique options like green tea and lemon basil.

BrewRiver GastroPub

If you're looking for a boozy twist on your ice cream, head to BrewRiver GastroPub. This restaurant offers a variety of adult milkshakes, made with premium ice cream and a variety of liquors. Their Bourbon & Brown Sugar shake is a popular choice, but they also offer a variety of other flavors.

Whit's Frozen Custard

Whit's is a Columbus-based chain that's been expanding into Cincinnati in recent years. Their frozen custard is made fresh daily, and they offer a variety of flavors, as well as sundaes and shakes. Their Whitser sundae, which includes your choice of flavor, hot fudge, and nuts, is a local favorite.

Juice Bar & Smoothies

If you're looking for a healthier option, check out Juice Bar & Smoothies. This local chain offers a variety of smoothie bowls and vegan ice cream options made with fruit and coconut milk. Their Mint Chocolate Chip flavor is a popular choice, and all of their options are dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan.

Conclusion

No matter what your preferences are when it comes to ice cream, Cincinnati has something for everyone. Whether you're in the mood for classic flavors or something a little more unique, there's a local ice cream shop that will satisfy your cravings. So next time you're in the mood for something sweet, head to one of these top ice cream spots in Cincinnati.

Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati: Small-Batch, Artisanal TreatsIf you're looking for the best ice cream in Cincinnati, you'll find small-batch, artisanal treats at their finest. From locally sourced ingredients to unique flavors that will surprise and delight your taste buds, Cincinnati has some of the best ice cream shops around. Whether you're a fan of classic flavors or innovative combinations, here are ten ice cream shops that you must try in Cincinnati.1. Graeter's Ice CreamGraeter's Ice Cream is a Cincinnati institution. This family-owned and operated ice cream shop has been serving up delicious treats since 1870. Graeter's uses only the freshest and highest quality ingredients to make their small-batch ice cream. They also use a French pot process that produces a rich and creamy texture. One of their most popular flavors is Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, but you can't go wrong with any of their classic flavors like Vanilla Bean or Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough.2. Aglamesis BrothersAglamesis Brothers has been a Cincinnati favorite since 1908. This family-owned ice cream shop uses locally sourced ingredients for the freshest taste. They also make their ice cream in small batches to ensure the highest quality. Some of their unique flavors include Buckeye Blitz (peanut butter ice cream with chocolate chips and peanut butter cups) and Cherry Chocolate Chunk.3. Dojo GelatoDojo Gelato is a small-batch gelato shop that uses traditional Italian methods to create their delicious treats. They use fresh and natural ingredients to make their gelato, sorbetto, and vegan options. Some of their unique flavors include Avocado, Brown Butter Bourbon Pecan, and Goat Cheese Caramel.4. Buzzed Bull CreameryBuzzed Bull Creamery is a unique ice cream shop that specializes in alcohol-infused ice cream. They use liquid nitrogen to freeze their ice cream on the spot, creating a smooth and creamy texture. Some of their flavors include Bourbon Brown Sugar, Pina Colada, and Rum Raisin.5. StreetpopsStreetpops is a popsicle shop that uses locally sourced ingredients to make their all-natural treats. They have a variety of flavors, including seasonal options like Pumpkin Pie and Apple Cider. Their popsicles are perfect for a hot summer day, and they also offer vegan and dairy-free options.6. Graeter's Scoops and ChutesGraeter's Scoops and Chutes is a unique ice cream shop located inside the Cincinnati Zoo. They offer classic flavors like Mint Chocolate Chip and Strawberry, as well as seasonal options like Blueberry Pie and Pumpkin. You can also enjoy their delicious ice cream while watching the animals at the zoo.7. Madisono's GelatoMadisono's Gelato is a small-batch gelato shop that uses local and organic ingredients to create their delicious treats. They have a variety of flavors, including Dairy-Free Chocolate, Lavender Honey, and Roasted Peach. They also offer creative sundae combinations that will make your mouth water.8. United Dairy FarmersUnited Dairy Farmers is a chain of ice cream shops that started in Cincinnati. They offer classic flavors like Vanilla and Chocolate, as well as unique flavors like Buckeye Fever and Black Cherry Amaretto. They also have a variety of ice cream sandwiches and other desserts that are worth the trip alone.9. Jolly's Drive-InJolly's Drive-In is a classic drive-in restaurant that has been serving up ice cream since 1947. They offer classic flavors like Butter Pecan and Mint Chocolate Chip, as well as seasonal options like Eggnog and Pumpkin Pie. They also have creative sundae combinations and ice cream floats.10. The ConeThe Cone is a family-owned ice cream shop that has been serving up delicious treats since 1965. They offer classic flavors like Chocolate and Strawberry, as well as unique flavors like Blue Moon and Superman. They also have ice cream flights for the indecisive – try a little bit of everything!In conclusion, Cincinnati has some of the best ice cream shops around. From small-batch, artisanal treats to classic flavors done to perfection, there is something for everyone. Whether you're a fan of gelato, popsicles, or alcohol-infused ice cream, these ten ice cream shops are a must-try. So why not treat yourself to a sweet and creamy treat today?

Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati: A Point of View

The Pros and Cons of the Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati

As an avid ice cream enthusiast, I have had the opportunity to try many different ice cream shops in Cincinnati. While each shop has its own unique flavor and style, there are a few that stand out above the rest.

The Pros:

Flavor Variety - The best ice cream shops in Cincinnati offer a wide variety of flavors from classic vanilla to more unique options like lavender honey.
Fresh Ingredients - Many of the top ice cream shops in Cincinnati use locally-sourced and fresh ingredients, resulting in a fresher and more flavorful ice cream.
Creative Flavors - The best ice cream shops in Cincinnati are always coming up with new and creative flavors that keep customers coming back for more.
Community Involvement - Many of the top ice cream shops in Cincinnati are involved in the community, supporting local events and charities.

The Cons:

Price - The best ice cream in Cincinnati can be expensive, especially if you opt for specialty flavors or toppings.
Long Lines - During peak hours, the best ice cream shops in Cincinnati can have long lines that require patience and time.
Limited Seating - Some of the top ice cream shops in Cincinnati have limited seating or outdoor-only seating, which can be inconvenient in extreme weather conditions.
Accessibility - Not all of the best ice cream shops in Cincinnati are located in easily accessible areas, requiring transportation or additional effort to visit.

Comparison of Top Ice Cream Shops in Cincinnati

Here is a table comparison of some of the top ice cream shops in Cincinnati:

Ice Cream Shop	Flavor Variety	Fresh Ingredients	Creative Flavors	Community Involvement	Price	Long Lines	Limited Seating	Accessibility
Graeter's	5/5	4/5	4/5	3/5	$$	3/5	2/5	3/5
Aglamesis Brothers	4/5	5/5	3/5	4/5	$$$	2/5	3/5	4/5
Dojo Gelato	5/5	5/5	5/5	3/5	$$	4/5	3/5	3/5
Zip Dip	4/5	3/5	2/5	2/5	$	4/5	4/5	4/5

Overall, the best ice cream in Cincinnati can be found at a variety of shops, each with its own pros and cons. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and priorities when it comes to flavor, quality, price, and convenience.

The Best Ice Cream in Cincinnati: A Sweet Journey

Thank you for taking the time to read about our exploration of the best ice cream in Cincinnati. We hope that our journey has inspired you to try new flavors and establishments in your own city or town. As we conclude our blog, we want to leave you with some final thoughts and recommendations.

First and foremost, we cannot stress enough the importance of supporting local businesses. Cincinnati has a thriving food scene, and there are countless ice cream shops that deserve your attention. By choosing to patronize these establishments, you are not only getting a delicious treat, but you are also contributing to the local economy and helping to keep unique businesses alive.

As for our top picks, it is difficult to choose just one favorite. Each shop we visited had its own unique charm and flavor offerings. If you are looking for classic, creamy ice cream, Graeter's is a must-try. Their French Pot process produces a rich, dense texture and their signature flavors, like Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, are beloved by locals and visitors alike.

If you are feeling adventurous, head to Buzzed Bull Creamery for their boozy ice cream creations. The combination of alcohol and ice cream may sound strange, but trust us - it works. From margarita sorbet to bourbon pecan, there is something for every palate at this innovative shop.

Similarly, if you are a fan of unconventional flavor combinations, Aglamesis Brothers is the place for you. Their menu boasts flavors like lavender honey and maple bacon, as well as more traditional options. With over 100 years of history in the Cincinnati area, Aglamesis Brothers is a true institution.

If you are looking for a more low-key spot, check out Dojo Gelato. With locations in Findlay Market and Northside, this gelato shop offers a rotating selection of flavors that are made in small batches using fresh, local ingredients. Their passion for quality is evident in every scoop.

And finally, we cannot forget about the vegan and dairy-free options available in Cincinnati. Whether you are vegan or simply looking to cut back on dairy, there are plenty of shops that cater to your needs. Our personal favorite was The Sweet Place, which offers a variety of vegan and gluten-free options that are just as tasty as their dairy-based counterparts.

Overall, our journey through Cincinnati's ice cream scene was a sweet success. We hope that you have enjoyed reading about our experiences and that you will be inspired to try some of these shops for yourself. Remember to support local businesses, try new flavors, and most importantly, savor every scoop!